BACK
TO NEWS
News
December 4, 2009
Religious Denominations Support
Maintaining
The Status Quo on Abortion in Health Care Reform
The undersigned religious and religiously affiliated organizations
urge the Senate to support comprehensive, quality health care reform
that maintains the current Senate language on abortion services.
We believe that it is our social and moral obligation to ensure access
to high quality comprehensive health care services at every stage in
an individual’s life. Reforming the health care system in a way
that guarantees affordable and accessible care for all is not simply
a good idea—it is necessary for the well-being of all people in
our nation.
The passage of meaningful health reform legislation will make significant
strides toward accomplishing the important goal of access to health
care for all. Unfortunately, the House-passed version of health reform
includes language that imposes significant new restrictions on access
to abortion services. This provision would result in women losing health
coverage they currently have, an unfortunate contradiction to the basic
guiding principle of health care reform. Providing affordable, accessible
health care to all Americans is a moral imperative that unites Americans
of many faith traditions. The selective withdrawal of critical health
coverage from women is both a violation of this imperative and a betrayal
of the public good.
The use of this legislation to advance new restrictions on abortion
services that surpass those in current law will serve only to derail
this important bill. The Senate bill is already abortion neutral, an
appropriate reflection of the fact that it is intended to serve Americans
of many diverse religious and moral views. The bill includes compromise
language that maintains current law, prohibiting federal funds from
being used to pay for abortion services, while still allowing women
the option to use their own private funds to pay for abortion care.
American families should have the opportunity to choose health coverage
that reflects their own values and medical needs, a principle that should
not be sacrificed in service of any political agenda.
We urge the Senate to support meaningful health reform that maintains
the compromise language on abortion services currently in the bill.
Respectfully,
Catholics for Choice
Disciples Justice Action Network
The Episcopal Church
Jewish Women International
NA’AMAT USA
National Council of Jewish Women
Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) Washington Office
Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice
The Religious Institute
Union of Reform Judaism
United Church of Christ, Justice and Witness Ministries
United Methodist Church-General Board of Church and Society
Unitarian Universalist Association of Congregations
United Church of Christ Justice
and Witness Ministries Statement
December 7, 2009
M. Linda Jaramillo
Executive Minister
Choice for Everyone
Just when I thought there was a glimmer of hope for women to really
have equal rights in America, backroom politics once again favors those
who make decisions “for women” rather than “with women.”
In this country, we tout the rhetoric of self-determination. However,
self-determination does not seem to play out for anyone but the rich
and powerful.
For several weeks, we offered our Witness for Justice weekly opinion
focused on health care justice. We shared various perspectives encouraging
our elected leaders in the House of Representatives to consider access
to health care as a moral issue. What we meant was that it is a moral
issue for everyone – not just some.
Sadly, in the final hours of the debate on November 7 when the historic
vote was taken, Congressmen Stupak and Pitts persuaded the House that
the only way to pass the health care reform bill was to limit women’s
access to reproductive services. These two men from Michigan and Pennsylvania
used a narrow religious moral argument to convince their colleagues,
citing the opinion of “religious leaders” as their premise.
They do not speak for all religious leaders and people of faith. They
do not speak for me as a religious leader with a deep Christian conviction
to justice, fairness, and self-determination.
We join the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, whose 40 participating
organizations represent more than 10,000 religious leaders and millions
of people of faith who believe that abortion must be safe, legal, and
accessible. We joined the leaders of Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, and
Interfaith organizations on November 16 to appeal to the Senate to consider
all religious perspectives with this statement:
The United Church of Christ joins many other faith groups in applauding
the House version of health care reform, which was passed on November
7, 2009, as a good step towards providing affordable health care for
more Americans. However, we express our disappointment that the House
bowed to pressure exerted at the last minute by attaching the Stupak/Pitts
Amendment to the bill.
The General Synod of the United Church of Christ has for 40 years
supported the full range of reproductive health care for women, including
access to abortion. And yet, once again, women’s health and well-being
have been compromised away in the halls of Congress. We call upon the
leadership in the House and Senate to boldly stand up for women’s
reproductive health care rights and join the majority of religious Americans
who believe that decisions around the termination of a pregnancy are
a private matter between a woman and her physician.
Knowing that women still earn an average of 70% of what men earn
even after the Fair and Equal Pay Act passed 40 years ago. Knowing that
women live longer than men and older women still receive reduced social
security benefits because of lower wages. Knowing that women’s
health care needs are still not met, I still hoped that this time –
maybe this time it would be different. I hoped that all women –
not just those who can afford it -- would have the choice about whether
and when to have children.
It’s not too late; there is still time to be heard. Go to
the website of The Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice to find
out how you can be heard, http://www.rcrc.org.
The United Church of Christ has more than 5,300 churches throughout
the United States. Rooted in the Christian traditions of congregational
governance and covenantal relationships, each UCC setting speaks only
for itself and not on behalf of every UCC congregation. UCC members
and churches are free to differ on important social issues, even as
the UCC remains principally committed to unity in the midst of our diversity.
12/04/2009
Religious Leaders and First
Amendment Advocates Call on Senate to Ensure Full Access to Reproductive
Health Services in Health Care Reform
November 16, 2009
Washington, DC - Heads of Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, interfaith
and First Amendment organizations today called on the Senate to ensure
the final health care reform bill respects diverse religious beliefs.
“It is now up to the Senate to keep health care reform free
of religious doctrine and restrictions that will prevent women from
making their own reproductive health care choices,” said Reverend
Dr. Carlton W. Veazey, President and CEO of the Religious Coalition
for Reproductive Choice (RCRC), which convened today’s news conference.
RCRC includes more than 40 denominations and religious organizations
that respect diverse religious beliefs and individual decisions about
whether and when to have children. The participating organizations together
represent more than 10,000 religious leaders and millions of people
of faith who believe that abortion must be safe, legal and accessible.
“We speak as people of faith who support religious freedom and
reproductive options,” said Reverend Veazey. “Women must
not lose access to abortion services they may need because of a small
but vocal group of anti-choice activists.”
Speakers included Linda Bales Todd of the General Board of Church and
Society of the United Methodist Church; Sammie Moshenberg, Director
of the Washington Office of the National Council of Jewish Women; Jon
O’Brien, President of Catholics for Choice; Sandra Sorensen, Director
of the Washington Office of the United Church of Christ Justice and
Witness Ministries, and Reverend Barry W. Lynn, Executive Director of
Americans United for Separation of Church and State.
Data from a public opinion poll of registered voters done by the Mellman
Group for the Women Donors Network and Communications Consortium Media
Center in late August was released. They showed significant support
across religions for the more moderate Capps Amendment to maintain the
status quo.
“There should be no Stupak-Pitts language in the Senate or conference
committee health care bills,” Reverend Veazey said. “Health
care reform is about expanding access to health care for all, not rolling
back women’s access to needed health services.”
##
Individual Statements:
Religious Coalition
for Reproductive Choice
General Board
of Church and Society, United Methodist Church
United Church of Christ,
Justice and Witness Ministries
National Council
of Jewish Women
Catholics for Choice
Americans United for
Separation of Church and State
No
Ideology in Health Care:
Statement of Reverend Dr. Carlton W. Veazey on House Passage of Stupak
Amendment
November 2, 2009
While we want health care reform, we are disturbed that the cost of
passing this legislation in the House of Representatives was greater
limitations on access to abortion. Just as appalling as the exemption
of this one medical service was the role of the U.S. Conference of Catholic
Bishops in assuring that their will be done. The bishops made clear,
through intense lobbying, that they would oppose health care reform
that did not specifically include their religious ideology.
Major Christian and Jewish denominations and millions
of Americans disagree with this position and support a woman's right
to make her own reproductive health decisions. This action by the House
is an unacceptable denial of our constitutional right to live according
to our own moral beliefs. As Congresswoman Barbara Lee noted in floor
debate on the legislation, "We're a democracy, not a theocracy."
Those who support access to all reproductive health services
want health care reform. We feel keenly our moral responsibility to
ensure the medical resources necessary for the health of all children,
families and communities. But this cannot be done without respect for
our nation's religious diversity. We call on the Senate to ensure that
health care reform is freed of religious ideology and restrictions
that will prevent women from making their own reproductive health
care choices.
Religious
Leaders' Statement on Health Reform: We support "a health care
system that is inclusive and respectful of diverse religious beliefs
and decisions" regarding childbearing.
Joint Statement of Religious
Leaders on Stupak Amendment
November 9, 2009
Catholics for Choice, the Planned Parenthood Federation of America Clergy
Network, the Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice, and the Religious
Institute on Sexual Morality, Justice, and Healing represent more than
10,000 religious leaders and tens of thousands of people of faith who
believe that abortion must be safe, legal, and accessible.
We come together to condemn the passage of the Stupak amendment, which if
passed by the Senate will effectively deny coverage for abortion services
to women covered by the new federal health care plan.
We are appalled that religious leaders intervened to impose their specific
religious doctrine into health care reform, not recognizing that women must
have the right to apply or reject the principles of their own faith in making
the decision as to whether or not abortion is appropriate in their specific
circumstances.
Further, we decry those who sought to use abortion as a way to scuttle much
needed health care reform.
We call on the President and the United States Senate to ensure that the
final bill that passes does not include any specific prohibition on the use
of federal funds for reproductive health care services. We pray for a renewed
commitment to relational and reproductive justice for all.
Signed:
The Rev. Dr. Ignacio Castuera, National Chaplain, Planned Parenthood
Federation of America
The Reverend Debra W. Haffner, Executive Director, Religious Institute
on Sexual Morality, Justice, and Healing
Jon O’Brien, President, Catholics for Choice
Reverend Dr. Carlton W. Veazey, President, Religious Coalition for
Reproductive Choice
|